Created with Sketch.
The Toothpick Review
31 minutes | Nov 1, 2018
Ep 29 – The Halloween Spooktacular
In this week’s episode, the gang catches up on some lost time and Mike tells some scary stories
66 minutes | Oct 9, 2018
Ep 28 – Live From Japan (w/ Sam Josephs and Renooka Karmarkar)
In this week’s episode, Shea, Riley, and Renooka interview Sam who is currently living in Japan. Topics discussed include international toothpicks, clothing sizes, and an extensive breakdown of Japanese toilets.
31 minutes | Sep 25, 2018
Ep 27 – You Won’t Believe What Mike Did This Time
In this week’s episode the gang plays some family friendly games, talks about the math behind couches, and learns about Mike’s dirty little secret.
40 minutes | Sep 18, 2018
Ep 26 – Marcus Reveals His Darkest Secret
In this week’s episode, Shea, Marcus, and Mike discuss Avatar the Last Airbender, math, and riddles. Also listen till the end to hear Marcus’ deepest secret.
53 minutes | Sep 11, 2018
Ep 25 – Season 2 Premier
In this week’s episode all four members of the gang get back together and catch up on Marcus’s and Riley’s summers.
52 minutes | Aug 28, 2018
Ep 24 – Season 1.5 Finale (w/ Evan Neilio and Marcus Mitchell)
Just skip this episode and come back next week.
44 minutes | Aug 21, 2018
Ep 23 – Saving Lives and Jacked Bald Men (w/ Ciaran Plunkett)
In this week’s episode Shea and Mike discuss all things lifeguarding with our friend and brother Ciaran Plunkett.
53 minutes | Aug 14, 2018
Ep 22 – Oui Oui Baguette (w/ Kaitlyn Gaffney)
In this week’s episode Shea and Mike discuss all things French with our friend Kaitlyn
48 minutes | Aug 7, 2018
Ep 21 – A 2008 Year in Review (w/ David and Matt Atkinson)
This this week’s episode, Shea and Mike welcome brothers Matt and David to the podcast to reminisce on old memories and recount the legendary year of 2008.
58 minutes | Jul 31, 2018
Ep 20 – President of the Toothclique (w/ Naheel Naber)
In this week’s episode, Shea and Mike welcome the leader of the Snollygosters, Naheel, to the pod to discuss her recent trip to Jordan, some presidential fun facts, and a certain cowboy who is all grown up.
60 minutes | Jul 25, 2018
Ep 19 – Vroom Vroom (w/ Charli XCX and Sam Trembly)
In this week’s episode, Shea and Mike welcome Sam back to the pod to discuss their trip to NY and meeting Charli XCX.
54 minutes | Jul 17, 2018
Ep 18 – Maggie’s Favorite Things (w/ Shea’s Mom, Maggie Plunkett)
In this week’s episode, Shea and Mike get school’d on how to make some fancy cocktails by Mrs. Plunkett, do a deep dive on Henry Winkler’s career, and DON’T get political.
40 minutes | Jul 11, 2018
Ep 17 – The Haunted Epsiode
In this week’s episode, Shea and Mike discuss Mike’s recent cross country road trip while the pod’s third member makes it’s presence known.
64 minutes | Jul 4, 2018
Ep 16 – The World Cup (w/ Matt Atkinson and Jason Baranowski)
In this week’s episode, the Shea and Mike welcome Matt and Jason to the pod. The group plays some “World Cup” trivia, gives some major bee updates and rambles on about New York concert goers.
57 minutes | Jun 26, 2018
Ep 15 – The Toothbick Review (w/ Sam Trembly)
In this week’s episode, the Shea and Mike welcome Sam to the pod. The group plays some Mike themed trivia, potentially starts a beef with Kendrick Lamar and takes a look at terrible company slogans throughout history.
41 minutes | Jun 19, 2018
Ep 14 – What’s That Sauce? (w/ Kevin Tierney and Evan Neilio)
In this week’s episode, the Shea and Mike welcome Evan and Kevin to the pod, determine the validity of rap lyrics, and taste some sauces.
53 minutes | Jun 13, 2018
Ep 13 – Summer in the City (w/ Riley’s Dad, Jack Shea)
In this week’s episode, the group says hello to their first ever podcast guest, discusses Shakespeare’s relationship to bees , and plays a round of Riley trivia.
42 minutes | Jun 5, 2018
Ep 12 – Riley Please Come Home, We Miss You (Season 1.5 Premier)
*SKIP TO MINUTE 15 IF YOU DON’T CARE ABOUT SPORTS* In this week’s episode the group sends out a cry for help for their friend Riley to come home. Other topics include fast foods from around the world, the effect of technology on the world, and SPORTS!
54 minutes | May 29, 2018
Ep 11 – Season 1 Finale
In this week’s episode, the group says goodbye to Riley, listens to the songs of the summer, and helps a listener with a Kia Soul problem.
42 minutes | May 22, 2018
Ep 10 – The Ballad of Kevin Bacon
In this week’s episode, the group debates whether Kevin Bacon is an A-list celebrity or not, discusses the prematures death of Riley’s beloved Tremors, and plays the Rotten Tomatoes game.
Terms of Service
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
© Stitcher 2022