Listen Now

Charlie is back from Oz. Twice! Jess is nervous and we love the episode. But seriously. Jess is very nervous. Matt's New Podcast: https://sites.libsyn.com/469407/GoodMovieBadMovie Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam, Dean, and Cas try to get Metatron to help remove the Mark of Cain, but he says it will cost them. Cas tries to help Claire even though she all she can do is attract the worst kind of people, and Rowena continues to manipulate Crowley (who totally thought he was about to go on a date with Dean). We discuss how we didn't get enough of Guthrie, how easy it is to fool angels, and how excited Crowley was to hang out with Dean again. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Cas goes in search of Claire Novak and finds that doing the right thing is complicated. When he brings in Sam and Dean to help, things get worse. Blood bath kind of worse. We are joined by returning guest TheXphial to discuss the terrible group home, Cas's great Jimmy impression, and just how different Dean gets around Cas. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

The team up you didn't know you needed? Jody and Donna!! We discuss how good this episode makes us feel, wonder why someone would investigate strange sounds (again), and we all hate Doug. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam and Dean are on the trail of a powerful witch who is attempting to build a new coven and kills a demon along the way. Crowley cannot stand for this and has her taken. Oh and Cole shows back up and something about Hannah kissing Cas. We discuss the return of the redhead, are oh so happen to finally talk about Rowena, and the knife-gun monster. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam and Dean find themselves in a real-life game of clue complete with all the weapons! But they have to hold the idiot ball for the plot to work and we're okay with that because it's quite entertaining. We discuss the Tony Hawk Pro Skater games, a new podcast that Jess recommends, and we have an old-fashioned tangent to start the episode. National Parks After Dark: https://www.npadpodcast.com/ Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

It's the show's 200th episode where Sam and Dean find themselves looking into a case that surrounds a high school play called Supernatural: The Musical (and it's amazing!) Martha is back as we discuss how much we love the episode. Everything about it. Even the deleted scenes. Delete Scenes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fVVXJSz-wd8&ab_channel=SupernaturalInsider Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

With Dean no longer a demon, it's time for him and Sam to take a break and go on vacation. Okay enough of that, time to take a case! Only this case leads them to someone they know who also is dealing with their sibling going down a dark path. We discuss how exactly Dean can be ready, how crying can be an effective form of manipulation, and how it's so easy to get away if you just run off camera. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Sam attempts to cure Dean, but he has no backup and things go poorly. Cas is trying to get to the bunker, but he's running out of grace and things go poorly. Crowley is back to running Hell and things go poorly. Jess has some feelings about Demon Dean, we think Jensen's directing saved the episode, and wonder if this is peak BuckLeming. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Cole is being ultra proud of himself saying all the things he thinks are cool to Sam, Dean fails at being a demon hitman, Crowley is desperate to save face, and Cas just needs a nap. Jess may have found her favorite episode in the series, Matt invents a new word, and discover which character needs therapy the most. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Dean is a demon and he's howling at the moon with Crowley. Sam doesn't know any of this and tracks down every lead he can to find his brother. Elsewhere, Cas helps Hannah track down two angels who refuse to return to Heaven. Oh and Cole shows up. Yay? We talk about how Pat Benatar makes everything better, How Osric kicked Jared's ass, and what Hannah needs to understand free will. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Welcome to a freebie episode! We've been practically harassing our listeners to write to us and write to us you did! So much so that this is part one of our mailbag series! Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Another season, another watchalong. Can you believe it? It might not be the best case the guys have taken, but it is when we first meet Donna so no complaints here! Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

The Mark of Cain vs the Word of God as Dean tracks down Metatron. Can Cas and Gadreel get to the angel tablet in time to give Dean the advantage or will something far worse happen? (It's Supernatural of course something worse will happen.) We discuss the movie Hook, how Sam did nothing to secure Dean or the First Blade, and what angels should be doing with their time. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Angels are turning themselves into suicide bombers and claim Castiel sent them. Cas seeks answers as he tracks down one of his subordinates with Sam while Dean stays behind to interrogate the reaper Tessa. We discuss all the continuity errors that annoy us, Cas's FBI cover name, and how badly the angels want to be in a cult. The Kitten Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ad25P7Nlf2I&ab_channel=WeLoveAnimals Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Cas calls Sam and Dean to help him interogate one of Metatron's minions. Then he sets up a secret meeting with Gadreel. Elsewhere, Abaddon has taken Crowley's son out of the past, into present day, and uses him as a bargaining chip to trap the Winchesters. Knowing they are walking into it, Dean feels confident he can kill the Knight of Hell. Yeah. A LOT goes on in this one. We discuss how Mark Sheppard sells all his lines, why Gavin doesn't die of 21st century diseases, and how great the Dean vs Abaddon scene is. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

An episode that was intended as a backdoor pilot for a spinoff that never came to be. Sam and Dean do little more than cameo in their own show so we are going to do the same. In order to bring you this episode, we had to call in the reinforcements. Also kids are in the background. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Jody gives Sam and Dean a call after she rescues a girl who was kept by vampires as a blood slave. Things get complicated when this girl refuses to offer any information since she views them as her family and only Jody seems to understand how delicate this all is. We wonder if these vampires are really all that bad, love everything Jody does, and worry for her safety all over again. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook

Unfortunately, we have to take a break for the next month. We plan to be back at the beginning of February with new episodes, new surprises, and lots of tangents. See you then!

Believing himself the hero of the story, Metatron tries to convince Cas to lead the opposition against him while Sam and Dean track down Gadreel. We discuss Jess's epic freak out at the return of THAT character, what a conversation would be like with an angel trying to use free will, and Cas's smile when Dean gets on the phone. Patreon Twitter Instagram Tumblr Facebook