Created with Sketch.
48 minutes | Sep 22, 2021
Cailey and Vanessa talk unsolved cases. Vanessa reviews the odd case of Edgar Allen Poe, and Cailey discusses the unsolved case of Artemus Ogeltree.
43 minutes | Aug 19, 2021
Guess Who's Back?!
Guess who is back! Vanessa talks about the Tylenol Murders and Cailey discusses the Exorcism of Anneliese Michel.
13 minutes | Jul 20, 2021
TV Show Trauma (Mini Episode)
Cailey returns with a short story of a TV Show murder case.
15 minutes | Jun 15, 2021
Cailey talks about the infamous case of the Granby Killdozer.
50 minutes | May 26, 2021
Cailey and Vanessa both discuss two cases of dating violence. Plus bonus content at the end of the episode!
41 minutes | May 11, 2021
Cailey Comes to Town...Again
Cailey comes back to Southern Illinois and talks about spooky adventures and Vanessa gives a very recent update about the Delphi Murders.
38 minutes | Apr 20, 2021
A Little Bit of This and A Little Bit of That
Vanessa gives another spooky update on her house and talks about an Easter Massacre. Cailey talks all about the famous Borden Murders.
46 minutes | Mar 29, 2021
Pick Your Poison
Cailey dives into Jones Town and Vanessa talks about the Mad Gasser of Mattoon.
37 minutes | Mar 23, 2021
Vanessa returns to join Cailey in telling some scary school stories.
12 minutes | Mar 15, 2021
(Mini) Episode 18: Happy St. Patrick's Day!
This week we make an exciting announcement, and Cailey dives into some St. Patrick's Day history!
28 minutes | Mar 9, 2021
Just Leave, Don't Kill!
This week Cailey and Vanessa both discuss cases that involve wives going a little too far.
33 minutes | Mar 2, 2021
The Stuff of Nightmares
Cailey talks about the awful incidents in Amityville and Vanessa talking about the nightmare that is the Island of the Dolls.
38 minutes | Feb 22, 2021
Vanessa and Cailey discuss heartbreaking cases right in time for Valentine's Day.
30 minutes | Feb 15, 2021
Horrors in the home
Cailey talks about the Annabelle the doll and Vanessa talks about the haunted Alfred Rosenheim Mansion.
37 minutes | Feb 4, 2021
Cailey and Vanessa dive into some unsolved family murders.
34 minutes | Jan 22, 2021
Cailey comes to town!
Cailey comes to southern Illinois and goes on adventures with Vanessa.
48 minutes | Jan 14, 2021
International Intrigue and Missing Mystery
Vanessa gives a spooky house update and discusses a missing case, and Cailey discusses an international case.
47 minutes | Jan 6, 2021
Urban Legends and a Spooky Sanatorium
Vanessa talks about Waverly Hills Sanatorium and Cailey dives into Colorado urban legends.
51 minutes | Dec 30, 2020
Cailey and Vanessa discuss serial killers in the Midwest, and Vanessa tells a spooky story from a previous episode.
36 minutes | Dec 17, 2020
Vanessa talk about the hauntings of the Congress Plaza Hotel in Chicago. Cailey dives into the haunted Hotel Colorado.
Terms of Service
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
© Stitcher 2021