Created with Sketch.
2 Girls, 1 Scaredy Cat
78 minutes | Nov 7, 2019
029: Derek Shepherd Likes Fishing
The next state-themed episode has arrived and this time it's North Carolina crimes! You'll hear about the strange circumstances and connection between Zebb Quinn and Cristie Schoen as well as the horrifying Lawson family murders.
48 minutes | Oct 23, 2019
Minisode 003: Airplanes
The girls struggle with accents and proper airline lingo in this week's minisode all about airplanes! Monica discusses the Tenerife airport disaster while Emilee chose the topic of the disappearance of Fredrick Valentich.
72 minutes | Oct 14, 2019
028: I'm Tony Romo!
This week, Monica and Emilee chose crimes copying movies for the theme and it was a whirlwind of terror! The American Beauty murder as well as a Scream copycat are discussed, along with some football and workplace (mis)conduct!
33 minutes | Oct 1, 2019
Minisode 002: Aliens
Do you think Wolf is a real fun guy? Do you watch Star Wars in your eyes? Do you like Owen Wilson? Then this alien-themed mini episode is perfect for you! Monica and Emilee finally discuss one of their favorite topics, including the 1561 celestial phenomenon over Nuremberg and the Wow! signal.
115 minutes | Sep 16, 2019
027: 2G1SC: The Musical
Excuse the singing throughout this episode, but the girls covered crimes that inspired future movies. This includes the Gainesville Ripper, which inspired Scream, and the murderesses Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner, who inspired Chicago, the musical.
35 minutes | Aug 27, 2019
Minisode 001: Local Legends
In their first mini episode, the girls talk about some of their favorite local legends, with the scaredy-cat adding her own story as well! Discussions include a haunted San Antonio hospital and the infamous goat-man.
104 minutes | Aug 20, 2019
026: Accomplished Accomplice
Welcome back to season two! Isabel and the girls hope you missed them and they also hope you really enjoy this first episode back from summer break! In this episode, you'll hear them discuss how the husband did it in the disappearances of both Monica Rizzo and Stacy Peterson.
154 minutes | Apr 27, 2019
025: Fish Fillet, Duh!
In what is their 25th episode, and the last episode of their first season, the girls and scaredy-cat make an important announcement! Two Girls, One Scaredy-Cat's second season will air in August, so please stay tuned for their return! The theme for season one's final episode is the crazy phenomenon folie à deux, or shared madness. Emilee chose to discuss the unbelievable Theranos/Elizabeth Holmes scandal while Monica picked the renowned "silent twins," or June and Jennifer Gibbons.
113 minutes | Apr 23, 2019
024: I Can't Lift My Kayak
In their second part-er for unsolved disappearances, the girls cover the cases of Madison Scott and Johnny Gosch.
112 minutes | Apr 16, 2019
023: Grandchild Sibling
This week, the girls discuss some conspiracy theories, such as the crazy Denver International Airport and the many conspiracies surrounding Beyoncé.
148 minutes | Apr 9, 2019
022: Live Dead Body
In what turned out to be a hilarious coincidence, Monica and Emilee both covered the same case for the Washington D.C.-themed episode! Listen to find out all about the strange and horrible murder of Robert Wone, why Emilee doesn't want to be stabbed in an LSU shirt, and how Isabel isn't a nurse.
88 minutes | Apr 1, 2019
021: Snakes Are Friends, Not Food
Monica and Emilee tackled poisonings in this week's episode while Isabel proves just how much she's likely to murder! Topics include the thallium poisoning of Zhu Ling and the unsolved poisoning of Patsy Wright.
108 minutes | Mar 25, 2019
020: Wrong Apostle
The eternal sleep awaits in this college/campus murder themed episode! Monica discusses the attack of Sarah Beard, Emilee chose Suzanne Jovin's murder, and Isabel fights her hangry-ness. Happy 20th episode!
102 minutes | Mar 19, 2019
019: They Were Roommates
This week, the episode theme is "you think you know it," where the girls cover well-known cases that people may have misconceptions about. Emilee discusses the Lorena Bobbitt case while Monica chose the murder of Meredith Kercher, or otherwise known as, the Amanda Knox case.
123 minutes | Mar 12, 2019
018: It's Not an Easter Egg
Internet homicide was the theme the girls chose for this week's episode and it was quite a doozy! The upsetting murder of Bobbie Jo Stinnet as well as the crazy story of Mark and John are just some of the stories of internet crazies the girls discussed this week.
86 minutes | Mar 4, 2019
017: Too Many Doors
While Isabel was incredibly freaked out by the spooky theme this week, the girls loved discussing haunted houses! Emilee chose the incredibly haunted Myrtles Plantation that's down in Louisiana and Monica discussed the Lawang Sewu building (with way too many doors!) located in Indonesia.
96 minutes | Mar 1, 2019
016: Rick Ross + Taylor Swift = Cult?
The girls really wanted to discuss cults for this episode and it was definitely a whirlwind! This episode will only cover the Branch Davidians down in Waco because we had some technical difficulties and lost Monica's part. Monica, Isabel, and Emilee still hope that you enjoy the episode and want you to let them know what you think! Don't forget to rate, review, and subscribe!
129 minutes | Feb 12, 2019
015: The Hill I Will Die On
For this week's episode, the girls tackled (excuse the pun!) athlete crimes, which led to the discussion of the infamous Aaron Hernandez case as well as Mark "Gator" Rogowski's rise and fall.
99 minutes | Jan 28, 2019
014: RIP Dobby
For this week's episode, it's the first of the 50 states that the girls plan to cover: Alaska! Monica covers Jane Reth and the murder of her husband, Scott, while Emilee discusses the maritime disaster that is the Princess Sophia.
138 minutes | Jan 21, 2019
013: Thicc Slender Man
The girls chose "killer kids" for the episode topic this week, where they then discuss the Slender Man stabbing and the murder of James "Jamie" Bulger.
Terms of Service
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
© Stitcher 2022