Snow, trees, holiday cheer, and it being December all sound like holiday movie elements. But add in Bigfootmania, Tom Lennon with his Monster Finder reality show, furries, Judy Greer playing the supportive barista (because of course; give her more leading roles, Hollywoo), an alcoholic Ian McShane, and now we’re confused. And did we mention furries? But that’s Pottersville for ya! Does it matter that we watched this in January? No because Netflix doesn’t care what month it is (and neither do our holiday hearts). This episode mostly pertains of Josh and Steph putting on their detective hats and trying to answer some real Burning Questions(TM). Who is this movie for? How did they get such big name actors? And will we ever recognize Christina Hendricks without red hair? Press play to get the scoop!