About This Show
Scott and Forrest have been called the 'Click and Clack of esoterica' by their listeners. Their mission is to take a look at legendary strange and unusual events from throughout history and interview people who've had close encounters with the unexplained. They strive to bring you everything that's entertaining about those stories and remind you that it's ok to laugh at scary stories and respectfully, even the people that tell them. Put your headphones on, settle in for you commute and get ready to experience a show like nothing you've ever heard before. New shows every two weeks.
Most Recent Episode
The Mothman (Part 1)
3 days ago
All legends are local in a way, and when one local person tells a tale of a strange encounter, it can be a cause for skeptical snickers from the townsfolk. When more than a hundred people from the same region all see the same thing, it can lead to books, a major Motion Picture and even an annual festival. Such is the case with Point Pleasant, West Virginia and the Ohio River Valley's own "Mothman"— whose local sightings turned into national legend. There are several elements that contribute to the intense curiosity that still surrounds the stories of the Mothman, himself described as a winged, humanoid creature with glowing red eyes and a sympathetic, if mysterious nature. One of them is the sudden appearance of a friendly, inter-dimensional road tripper named Indrid Cold who just wants to get to know you better and may be searching for a cryptid on the loose . Another is the unsettling thought that these encounters may have portended a disaster that took the lives of 46 people exactly 13 months later.
“Human beings are under the control of a strange force that bends them in absurd ways, forcing them to play a role in a bizarre game of deception.” -
— Jacques Vallée, Computer Scientist, Venture Capitalist and noted Ufologist
We've found that some sites are not showing these links as clickable unless they are URLs, so until those outlets improve their show notes section, we are providing actual URLs next to the clickable description of each link to make things easier for our listeners!
The Mothman Prophecies - A True Story by John A. Keel https://amzn.com/0765334984
The Mothman Prophecies - The Movie https://amzn.com/B0000648X0
The Woodrow Derenberger interview with Ronald Maines, Gen. Mgr. of WTAP https://youtu.be/5HxY4suVjSo
Point Pleasant, West Virginia http://bit.ly/2euHGdZ
Gallipolis, Ohio basecamp for John Keel and the Mothman Prophecies movie crew http://bit.ly/2e3aZpU
Visit the Mothman Museum! http://bit.ly/2enKY4d
Attend the Mothman Festival in beautiful Point Pleasant, WV! http://bit.ly/1pjsSMO
Scott always stays at the Lowe Hotel when searching for Mothman! http://www.thelowehotel.com/
Point Pleasant's "TNT Area" where the Mothman dwells http://n.pr/2drLM5A
Explosion and munitions risk at the "TNT Area" http://bit.ly/2eIfuJD
Inside the Eerie TNT Storage Bunkers of West Virginia on Wired http://bit.ly/2e8qeyV
The Mothman and Indrid Cold story on WeekInWeird.com http://bit.
Rated 1 out of
Ugh Simply Ugh
Just So Bad
I enjoy many GOOD mystery themed podcasts, this is not one of those. It's hard to pin down a single thing wrong with this show but here are a few. The hosts use logically fallacious arguments and/or straw-man arguments They leave out well known information that point to prosaic reasons for the "mysteries" they present. Whether done intentionally or through shoddy research it's unforgivable to leave out pertinent information. The personalities of the hosts are also grating but that might be a side effect of their propensity to wander off topic regularly.
Date published: 2016-08-10
Rated 5 out of
One of my favs
I personally like the banter between the hosts. I appreciate how in-depth their research goes into the history of the subject. It gives the listener a more complete picture of the story. Many of these subjects I've heard covered in other podcasts, but Scott, Forrest and the ARC always come up with new details or backstory that I haven't heard previously. I appreciate them having "a take" at the end as well.
Date published: 2016-10-14
Rated 5 out of
The Eastern Border
As the title says - astonishing.
I can only presume that when they picked the show's name, they were talking about themselves. Scott and Forrest are both astonishing and legends. Superbly researched, highly entertaining and extremely well produced - this show is everything you'd want form a mystery/supernatural/unexplained podcast, and then some.
Also, Zeitgeist. This show has lots of it.
Date published: 2016-04-19
Rated 5 out of
LOVE this show
Two intelligent guys discuss legends and lore with extensive research. But they maintain a self-aware sense of "what if" that keeps the mysteries fascinating and the show very binge-able.
Date published: 2016-04-27
Rated 2 out of
Passion Project Turned Into Cash Cow
It took the hosts some time to hit their stride, but by the time they got to the Dylatov Pass episode, this podcast was great. Genuinely great. There was a delightful balance between humor, off-the-cuff banter, and thoughtful consideration and explanation of research. It was clear that the hosts were doing a lot of their own research, and that grunt work equipped them to discuss content with fluency and enthusiasm that only comes from showing off the findings of your own hard work.
But then the podcast started getting popular, they started adding more and more advertisements, and this podcast became the full-time gig for at least one host. And everything started falling apart then. It's not just the excessive ads -- and they ARE excessive. I listen to 12+ podcasts regularly, many of them started out small-time and are now careers for the hosts, but not a single one of the others has so many or such lengthy ad spots per episode. In fact, the latest episode, "Monsters Among Us" is literally 1:55:33 of an advertisement. It's all about an upcoming book by the same title, they interview the author, they plug and praise the book repeatedly, and they even read whole stories from the book. It's 2 hours of advertising. It's not even interesting advertising.
Annoying as they are, my biggest problem with recent episodes isn't the ads.
One major problem is the disorganization, lack of detail, and the sharp increase in fallacious, sloppy logic and analysis. I think a variety of poor choices on the part of the hosts has led to this. They have volunteers doing huge amounts of their research for them, and while this makes sense to a degree, the result is the hosts are very obviously less familiar with the content they present. It results in vague descriptions, disjointed analysis, and repeated statements and conclusions that are so silly, so obviously biased, and so far from skeptical or logical that I can't help but feel like Scott and Forrest no longer listen to themselves speak. One can't help but wonder if success has gone to their heads a bit. What made them great (at one time) was their effort. Now they seem to think they've made it and can rest on their laurels. They ramble. They contradict themselves. They are prone to excessive "or somethings" and "uhhh, yeah, I think so..." It's disappointing.
Another significant problem is the content being chosen lately. I think these two may have bitten off more than they can chew and are struggling to produce quality episodes quickly. It's to the point that 75% of the episodes feel like "filler" while you wait for an occasional interesting series on one event/phenomenon. The book promotion episode "Monsters Among Us" was the worst of these to date, but they've also botched what could've been great topics. The Mary Celeste, for example, was unnecessarily stretched over 3 episodes just to fit their new series format (3 episodes each week followed by an off week). I'm a college professor and couldn't shake the feeling I was watching a half-drunk freshman try to stretch a few paragraphs into a 3-page essay. It was annoying. It was boring. It's insulting as a listener who has financially supported this project previously.
My strong sense is that the hosts are increasingly disengaged from what was once a passion project and is now a cash cow. It's made a great podcast mediocre at best. Good things never last, I guess. I will no longer be listening.
Date published: 2016-10-08